VSE GOALIE RANKINGS

1. TOM BRADY

2. JOE MONTANA

3. PEYTON MANNING

4. PATRICK MAHOMES

5. JOHN ELWAY

6. DAN MARINO

7. BRETT FAVRE

8. KURT WARNER

9. TROY AIKMAN

10. ROGER STAUBACH

11. TERRY BRADSHAW 

12. AARON RODGERS

13. DREW BREES

14. STEVE YOUNG

15. JIM KELLY

16. KEN STABLER

17. DAN FOUTS

18. FRAN TARKENTON

19. BOB GRIESE

20. RUSSELL WILSON

21. BEN ROETHLISBERGER

22. ELI MANNING

23. KEN ANDERSON

24. WARREN MOON

25. JOE THEISMANN

26. JIM PLUNKETT

27. MATT RYAN

28. PHIL SIMMS

29. JOE NAMATH

30. MATTHEW STAFFORD

31. RANDALL CUNNINGHAM

32. PHILIP RIVERS

33. RICH GANNON

34. BOOMER ESIASON

35. JOE FLACCO

36. DONOVAN MCNABB

37. DANNY WHITE

38. STEVE MCNAIR

39. TONY ROMO

40. BERT JONES

41. DAVE KRIEG

42. STEVE BARTKOWSKI

43. CRAIG MORTON

44. JOSH ALLEN

45. CARSON PALMER

46. CAM NEWTON

47. DREW BLEDSOE

48. MARK BRUNELL

49. RON JAWORSKI

50. JOE FERGUSON

HM JEFF HOSTETLER

HM MARK RYPIEN

HM BRAD JOHNSON

HM ANDREW LUCK

HM KIRK COUSINS

HM BRIAN SIPE

HM DAK PRESCOTT

HM JARED GOFF

HM CHAD PENNINGTON

HM JIM EVERETT

FORMULA CONSIDERING WINS, STATISTICAL ANALYSIS, POSTSEASON SUCCESS, AWARDS, AND SCHEDULE.  66 SEASONS HAVE QUALIFIED AS "ELITE" SINCE 1970.

 1. PEYTON MANNING (7)

2T. TOM BRADY (5)

2T. JOE MONTANA (5)

4. STEVE YOUNG (4)

5T. TROY AIKMAN (3)

  5T. DREW BREES (3)

5T. BRETT FAVRE (3)

8T. KEN ANDERSON (2)

8T. TERRY BRADSHAW (2)

8T. DAN FOUTS (2)

8T. JIM KELLY (2)

8T. DAN MARINO (2)

8T. PATRICK MAHOMES (2)

8T. AARON RODGERS (2)

8T. KEN STABLER (2)

8T. ROGER STAUBACH (2)

8T. JOE THEISMANN (2)

8T. KURT WARNER (2)

* 45.5% OF ALL ELITE SEASONS SINCE 1970 WERE FROM SEVEN SIGNAL CALLERS:  P. MANNING, BRADY, MONTANA, YOUNG, AIKMAN, BREES, FAVRE

BEST OVERALL SEASONS

BEST REGULAR SEASONS

BEST STANLEY CUP SEASONS

70s

80s

90s

00s

10s

20s

BEST BY TEAM

BEST BY COUNTRY

LEADERS IN SEASONS WITH ABOVE-AVERAGE WINNING PERCENTAGE

1. TOM BRADY (19)

2. PEYTON MANNING (14)

3T. BRETT FAVRE (10)

3T. AARON RODGERS (10)

5. JOHN ELWAY (9)

6. RUSSELL WILSON (8)

7. ROGER STAUBACH (7)

7T. BEN ROETHLISBERGER (7)

9T. JOE MONTANA (6)

9T. DREW BREES (6)

9T. JIM KELLY (6)

9T. MATT RYAN (6)

PERCENTAGE OF TOP THREE FINISHES IN THE FOUR MAJOR STATISTICAL PASSING CATEGORIES THROUGHOUT CAREER

1. PEYTON MANNING (57.4%)

2. DREW BREES (46.3%)

3. STEVE YOUNG (36.7%)

4. JOE MONTANA (35.0%)

5. DAN MARINO (33.8%)

6. FRAN TARKENTON (33.3%)

7. ROGER STAUBACH (31.8%)

8. KURT WARNER (29.2%)

9. PATRICK MAHOMES (28.6%)

10. BRETT FAVRE (27.5%)

 SIGNAL CALLERS EVALUATED BY BEST FIVE CONSECUTIVE SEASONS (OVER 100 ACCUMULATED POINTS VIA VSE FORMULA)

 1. PEYTON MANNING (2003-2007) - 144

2. STEVE YOUNG (1992-1996) - 141

3. PATRICK MAHOMES (2018-2022) - 137

4. BRETT FAVRE (1994-1998) - 132

5. DREW BREES (2009-2013) - 126

6. JOE MONTANA (1986-1990) - 122

7. TOM BRADY (2003-2007) - 121

8. TOM BRADY (2016-2020) - 115

9. DAN MARINO (1984-1988) - 113

10. JOE MONTANA (1981-1985) - 111

11. TROY AIKMAN (1992-1996) - 110

12. KEN STABLER (1973-1977) - 109

13T. DAN FOUTS (1978-1982) - 108.5

13T. FRAN TARKENTON (1972-1976) - 108.5

15. TOM BRADY (2010-2014) - 100

SIGNAL CALLERS EVALUATED BY BEST FIVE TOTAL SEASONS, CONSECUTIVE OR NON-CONSECUTIVE (OVER 100 ACCUMULATED POINTS VIA VSE FORMULA)

1. PEYTON MANNING (168)

2T. JOE MONTANA (158)

2T. STEVE YOUNG (158)

4. TOM BRADY (152)

5. DREW BREES (139)

6. BRETT FAVRE (136)

7. PATRICK MAHOMES (134)

8. AARON RODGERS (133.5)

9. KURT WARNER (131)

10. DAN MARINO (126)

11. ROGER STAUBACH (124)

12. TERRY BRADSHAW (114)

13. FRAN TARKENTON (112.5)

14. TROY AIKMAN (110)

15T. DAN FOUTS (109.5)

15T. KEN STABLER (109.5)

17. KEN ANDERSON (109)

REGULAR SEASON

325 COMP  499 ATT  65.1%  4353 YDS  41 TD

PLAYOFFS

77 COMP  121 ATT  63.6%  1063 YDS  8 TD

13 REGULAR SEASON WINS

NFL MVP

FIRST TEAM ALL-PRO

LED NFL IN TD, COMP % & PASS RTG

SECOND IN YDS

SUPER BOWL CHAMPION

SUPER BOWL MVP

TOTAL POINTS:  45

REGULAR SEASON

324 COMP  461 ATT  70.3%  3969 YDS  35 TD

PLAYOFFS

53 COMP  87 ATT  60.9%  623 YDS  9 TD

13 REGULAR SEASON WINS

NFL MVP

FIRST TEAM ALL-PRO

LED NFL IN TD, COMP % & PASS RTG

SUPER BOWL CHAMPION

SUPER BOWL MVP

TOTAL POINTS:  42

REGULAR SEASON

398 COMP  578 ATT  68.9% 4806 YDS 50 TD

POSTSEASON

77 COMP  109 YDS  70.6%  737 YDS  6 TD

16 REGULAR SEASON WINS

NFL MVP

FIRST TEAM ALL-PRO

LED NFL IN YDS, TD, COMP %, & PASS RTG*

SUPER BOWL FINALST

* "QUADRUPLE CROWN" ACCOMPLISHED TWICE SINCE 1970 (WARNER 2001)

TOTAL POINTS:  41

REGULAR SEASON

435 COMP  648 ATT  67.1%  5250 YDS  41 TD

POSTSEASON

72 COMP  100 ATT  72.0%  703 YDS  7 TD

14 REGULAR SEASON WINS

NFL MVP

FIRST TEAM ALL-PRO

LED NFL IN YDS & TD

SECOND IN PASS RTG

SUPER BOWL CHAMPION

SUPER BOWL MVP

TOTAL POINTS:  40.5

REGULAR SEASON

375 COMP  546 ATT  68.7% 4830 YDS  36 TD

PLAYOFFS

68 COMP  107 ATT  63.6%  793 YDS  4 TD

14 REGULAR SEASON WINS

NFL MVP

FIRST TEAM ALL-PRO

LED NFL IN YDS, TD, COMP %, & PASS RTG*

SUPER BOWL FINALIST

* "QUADRUPLE CROWN" ACCOMPLISHED TWICE SINCE 1970 (BRADY 2007)

TOTAL POINTS:  39

REGULAR SEASON

207 COMP  368 ATT  56.3%  2915 YDS  28 TD

PLAYOFFS

44 COMP  78 ATT  56.4%  790 YDS  8 TD

14 REGULAR SEASON WINS

NFL MVP

FIRST TEAM ALL-PRO

LED NFL IN TD

SECOND IN PASS RTG 

SUPER BOWL CHAMPION

SUPER BOWL MVP

TOTAL POINTS:  38.5

REGULAR SEASON

362 COMP  557 ATT  65.0%  4397 YDS  31 TD

PLAYOFFS

97 COMP  153 ATT  63.4%  1034 YDS  3 TD

12 REGULAR SEASON WINS

LED NFL IN TD, PASS RTG

SECOND IN YDS

THIRD IN COMP %

SUPER BOWL CHAMPION

SUPER BOWL MVP

TOTAL POINTS:  38

REGULAR SEASON

363 COMP  514 ATT  70.6%  4388 YDS  34 TD

PLAYOFFS

72 COMP  102 ATT  70.6%  732 YDS  8 TD

13 REGULAR SEASON WINS

LED NFL IN TD, COMP % & PASS RTG

SUPER BOWL CHAMPION

SUPER BOWL MVP

TOTAL POINTS:  38

REGULAR SEASON

362 COMP  564 ATT  64.2% 5084 YDS 48 TD

PLAYOFFS

71 COMP  116 ATT  61.2%  1001 YDS  8 TD

14 REGULAR SEASON WINS

NFL MVP

FIRST TEAM ALL-PRO

LED NFL IN YDS, TD & PASS RTG

THIRD IN COMP %

SUPER BOWL FINALIST

TOTAL POINTS:  37

REGULAR SEASON

268 COMP, 402 ATT, 66.7%, 3465 YDS, 25 TD

PLAYOFFS

45 COMP, 65 ATT, 69.2%, 540 YDS, 3 TD

14 REGULAR SEASON WINS

NFL MVP

FIRST TEAM ALL-PRO

LED NFL IN TD, COMP % & PASS RTG

SECOND IN YDS

NFC CHAMPIONSHIP FINALIST

TOTAL POINTS:  37

11. JOE MONTANA (1989)

12 - KEN STABLER (1976)

13T - JOHN BRODIE (1970)

13T - BRETT FAVRE (1996)

13T - JOE MONTANA (1984)

13T - FRAN TARKENTSON (1975)

17 - PEYTON MANNING (2013)

18T - PEYTON MANNING (2003)

18T - MARK RYPIEN (1991)

20T - BERT JONES (1976)

20T - PEYTON MANNING (2009)

20T - AARON RODGERS (2020)

23 - ROGER STAUBACH (1971)

24T - DREW BREES (2011)

24T - PEYTON MANNING (2004)

24T - MATT RYAN (2016)

27T - KEN ANDERSON (1981)

27T - BRETT FAVRE (1995)

27T - BRETT FAVRE (1997)

27T - JOE MONTANA (1981)

27T - AARON RODGERS (1997)

27T - BRIAN SIPE (1980)

27T - STEVE YOUNG (1993)

34T - TOM BRADY (2017)

34T - PATRICK MAHOMES (2018)

34T - JOE MONTANA (1987)

34T - ROGER STAUBACH (1977)

34T - JOE THEISMANN (1983)

 39T - TROY AIKMAN (1992)

39T - TOM BRADY (2010)

39T - RICH GANNON (2002)

39T - JIM KELLY (1991)

39T - PEYTON MANNING (2005)

39T - KEN STABLER (1974)

39T - JOE MONTANA (1990)

47 - BOB GRIESE (1977)

48T - TROY AIKMAN (1993)

48T - TOM BRADY (2016)

48T - TOM BRADY (2020)

48T - DAN FOUTS (1979)

48T - PEYTON MANNING (2012) 

 53T - TROY AIKMAN (1995)

53T - RANDALL CUNNINGHAM (1998)

53T - DAN MARINO (1985)

  56T - KEN ANDERSON (1975)

56T - DAN FOUTS (1982)

56T - DAK PRESCOTT (2023)

56T - MATTHEW STAFFORD (2021)

56T - JOE THEISMANN (1982)

 61T - TERRY BRADSHAW (1979)

61T - DREW BREES (2018)

61T - LAMAR JACKSON (2018)

61T - JIM KELLY (1990)

61T - PHIL SIMMS (1986)

61T - STEVE YOUNG (1998)

67T - AARON RODGERS (2021)

67T - ROGER STAUBACH (1973)

69T - TOM BRADY (2003)

69T - DREW BREES (2006)

69T - WARREN MOON (1990)

69T - AARON RODGERS (2014)

69T - FRAN TARKENTON (1973)

69T - STEVE YOUNG (1997)

74T - TOM BRADY (2021)

74T - FRAN TARKENTON (1973)

76T - TOM BRADY (2004)

76T - TOM BRADY (2014)

76T - DAN FOUTS (1981)

76T - DAN MARINO (1986)

76T - CAM NEWTON (2015)

76T - AARON RODGERS (2010)

76T - AARON RODGERS (2012)

76T - TONY ROMO (2014)

84T - TERRY BRADSHAW (1975)

84T - BOB GRIESE (1971)

84T - BOB GRIESE (1973)

84T - JOHN HADL (1973)

88T - TOM BRADY (2001)

88T - DAUNTE CULPEPPER (2004)

88T - JOHN ELWAY (1993)

88T - JIM EVERETT (1989)

88T - BRETT FAVRE (2009)

88T - DAN FOUTS (1980)

88T - PATRICK MAHOMES (2019)

88T - PATRICK MAHOMES (2020)

88T - CARSON PALMER (2005)

88T - CARSON PALMER (2015)

88T - KURT WARNER (2008)

88T - RUSSELL WILSON (2013)

100 - EARL MORRALL (1972)

* 67% OF THE TOP 100 SEASONS SINCE 1970 WERE FROM 15 SIGNAL CALLERS:  BRADY (10), P. MANNING (7), RODGERS (6), MONTANA (5), YOUNG (5), BREES (4), FAVRE (4), MAHOMES (4), AIKMAN (3), BRADSHAW (3), GRIESE (3), STAUBACH (3), WARNER (3)

FORMULA CONSIDERING WINS, STATISTICAL ANALYSIS, POSTSEASON SUCCESS, AWARDS, AND SCHEDULE.  569 SEASONS HAVE QUALIFIED AS "ABOVE AVERAGE" SINCE 1970.

 1. DALLAS (31)

2. MIAMI (29)

3T. NEW ENGLAND (27)

3T. SAN FRANCISCO (27)

5. MINNESOTA (26)

6. GREEN BAY (25)

7. CINCINNATI (23)

8. DENVER (22)

9T. IND/BAL COLTS (21)

9T. NEW ORLEANS (21) 

FORMULA CONSIDERING WINS, STATISTICAL ANALYSIS, POSTSEASON SUCCESS, AWARDS, AND SCHEDULE.  66 SEASONS HAVE QUALIFIED AS "ELITE" SINCE 1970.

1. SAN FRANCISCO (10)

2T. DALLAS (6)

2T. IND/BAL COLTS (6)

4. GREEN BAY (5)

5. NEW ENGLAND (4)

6T. CINCINNATI (3)

6T. LV/OAK/LA RAIDERS (3)

6T. LA/STL RAMS (3)

6T. MIAMI (3)

6T. NEW ORLEANS (3)

6T. WASHINGTON (3) 

1. NEW ENGLAND  2001-19 (19)

2. SAN FRANCISCO  1981-98 (18)

3. NEW ORLEANS  2006-20 (15)

4. MIAMI  1981-92 (12)

5T. DALLAS  1975-83 (9)

5T. IND/BAL COLTS  2002-10 (9)

5T. KANSAS CITY  2015-PRES (9)

5T. SEATTLE  2012-20 (9)

9T. DALLAS  1991-96 (6)

9T. GREEN BAY  1993-98 (6)

 1. ARI/PHO CARDINALS  1988-2007 (20)

2T. BAL/IND COLTS  1978-94 (17)

2T. KANSAS CITY  1973-89 (17)

2T. TAMPA BAY  1980-96 (17)

5. BUFFALO  2003-18 (16)

6. DETROIT  1996-2010 (15)

7. SEATTLE  1989-2002 (14)

8T. CINCINNATI  1990-2002 (13)

8T. OAKLAND  2003-2015 (13)

8T. MIAMI  2009-21 (13)

 1. KANSAS CITY (9-1)

2. SEATTLE (8-2)

3T. GREEN BAY (7-3)

3T. NEW ORLEANS (7-3)

5. NEW ENGLAND (6-4)

 28T. CHICAGO (1-9)

28T. CLEVELAND (1-9)

28T. JACKSONVILLE (1-9)

28T. NY GIANTS (1-9)

28T. NY JETS (1-9)

1. KANSAS CITY (+9)

2. BUFFALO (+5)

3. PHILADELPHIA (+2)

3T. MIAMI (+2)

5. FIVE TEAMS TIED AT +1

27T. CAROLINA (-6)

27T. JACKSONVILLE (-6)

29T. NY GIANTS (-7)

29T. WASHINGTON (-7)

31T. DENVER (-8)

31T. NY JETS (-8)